Here are the best and worst VA medical centers

By:  Leo Shane III 

WASHINGTON — Veterans Affairs officials claimed improvements at 66 percent of their medical centers across the country last fiscal year, with 18 earning the highest level of excellence in the department’s internal ratings system.

But nine others remain on the VA’s list of underperforming facilities after getting the lowest possible rating. They include the embattled Washington VA Medical Center, which sits just a few miles from the White House and has seen a series of leadership shake-ups in recent years.

The VA ratings — made public in 2016 after a USA Today report on the internal scorecards — grade each of the locations on metrics like patient mortality, patient length of stay, reported accidents and patient satisfaction. Officials have said the system is used to collect best practices from high-performing facilities to use in underperforming ones.

In a statement, VA Secretary Robert Wilkie touted improvements across the 146 medical centers.

“With closer monitoring and increased medical center leadership and support, we have seen solid improvements at most of our facilities,” he said. “Even our highest performing facilities are getting better, and that is driving up our quality standards across the country.”

The number of one-star facilities dropped by six from the start of fiscal 2018 to the end. Of the nine medical centers still at that level, four were cited for significant improvements: El Paso and Big Spring in Texas, Memphis in Tennessee, and Loma Linda in California.

The five others — Washington, Phoenix and Tucson in Arizona, Montgomery in Alabama, and Atlanta in Georgia — saw no overall change.

Earlier this year, VA placed 12 medical centers on a high-risk list for “aggressive” management intervention. Of those, eight were removed from the program after showing sufficient improvement by the end of last month.

Wilkie said while he is pleased with the results thus far “there’s no doubt that there’s still plenty of work to do.”

 

The full ratings list is available on the VA web site or in the chart below:

VISN

Medical Center

Relative Performance Star Rating (1 to 5)

Improvement From Baseline Scores 2017

5

Washington

1

No change

7

Atlanta

1

No change

7

Montgomery

1

No change

9

Memphis

1

Improvement (small)

17

Big Spring

1

Improvement (large)

17

El Paso

1

Improvement (large)

22

Loma Linda

1

Improvement (small)

22

Phoenix

1

No change

22

Tucson

1

No change

2

East Orange

2

Improvement (small)

5

Beckley

2

No change

5

Martinsburg

2

Improvement (small)

6

Fayetteville NC

2

No change

6

Hampton

2

No change

7

Augusta

2

No change

7

Columbia SC

2

Improvement (small)

8

Lake City

2

No change

8

San Juan

2

No change

9

Murfreesboro

2

Improvement (small)

9

Nashville

2

Improvement (small)

10

Battle Creek

2

Improvement (large)

10

Fort Wayne

2

Improvement (small)

15

Kansas City

2

Improvement (small)

15

Marion IL

2

Improvement (small)

16

Alexandria

2

No change

16

Gulf Coast HCS

2

No change

16

Jackson

2

Improvement (large)

17

Dallas

2

Improvement (small)

17

Harlingen

2

Improvement (large)

19

Cheyenne

2

No change

19

Denver

2

Improvement (small)

19

Montana

2

Improvement (small)

19

Muskogee

2

No change

19

Oklahoma City

2

Improvement (small)

20

Puget Sound

2

Improvement (small)

20

Roseburg

2

Improvement (small)

20

Walla Walla

2

Improvement (large)

21

Fresno

2

Improvement (small)

21

Honolulu

2

Improvement (small)

21

Las Vegas

2

Improvement (large)

21

Palo Alto

2

No change

22

Albuquerque

2

Improvement (small)

22

Long Beach

2

No change

22

Prescott

2

Improvement (small)

1

Manchester

3

Improvement (small)

1

Providence

3

No change

1

White River

3

Improvement (small)

2

Albany

3

Improvement (large)

2

Brooklyn

3

Improvement (small)

2

Hudson Valley

3

No change

2

Northport

3

No change

2

Syracuse

3

No change

4

Philadelphia

3

Improvement (small)

4

Wilkes Barre

3

No change

4

Wilmington

3

Improvement (large)

5

Baltimore

3

Improvement (small)

5

Perry Point

3

Improvement (large)

6

Durham

3

Improvement (small)

6

Salisbury

3

Improvement (small)

7

Dublin

3

Improvement (large)

7

Tuscaloosa

3

Improvement (small)

8

Bay Pines

3

No change

8

Gainesville

3

Improvement (small)

8

Miami

3

No change

8

Orlando

3

No change

8

West Palm

3

Improvement (large)

9

Louisville

3

No change

10

Ann Arbor

3

Improvement (small)

10

Dayton

3

No change

10

Detroit

3

Improvement (small)

10

Indianapolis

3

Improvement (small)

12

Chicago

3

Improvement (small)

12

Danville

3

Improvement (small)

12

Hines

3

Improvement (small)

12

Milwaukee

3

No change

12

Tomah

3

No change

15

Columbia MO

3

Improvement (small)

15

Poplar Bluff

3

No change

15

St Louis

3

Improvement (small)

15

Topeka

3

Improvement (small)

16

Fayetteville AR

3

No change

16

Houston

3

No change

16

Little Rock

3

Improvement (large)

16

New Orleans

3

Improvement (small)

16

Shreveport

3

Improvement (small)

17

San Antonio

3

Improvement (large)

17

Temple

3

Improvement (small)

19

Salt Lake City

3

No change

20

Anchorage

3

No change

20

Boise

3

No change

20

Portland

3

Improvement (large)

20

Spokane

3

Improvement (large)

20

White City

3

Improvement (large)

21

Reno

3

No change

21

Sacramento

3

Improvement (large)

21

San Francisco

3

Improvement (small)

22

Los Angeles

3

Improvement (small)

22

San Diego

3

No change

23

Fort Meade

3

No change

23

Iowa City

3

Improvement (small)

1

Boston

4

No change

2

Bronx

4

Improvement (small)

2

Buffalo

4

Improvement (large)

2

Canandaigua

4

Improvement (large)

2

New York

4

Improvement (small)

4

Altoona

4

No change

4

Pittsburgh

4

Improvement (small)

5

Clarksburg

4

Improvement (large)

5

Huntington

4

Improvement (large)

6

Richmond

4

No change

7

Birmingham

4

Improvement (small)

7

Charleston

4

No change

8

Tampa

4

No change

9

Lexington

4

Improvement (small)

9

Mountain Home

4

Improvement (small)

10

Chillicothe

4

No change

10

Columbus

4

Improvement (small)

12

North Chicago

4

No change

15

Leavenworth

4

Improvement (small)

15

Wichita

4

Improvement (small)

17

Amarillo

4

Improvement (large)

19

Grand Junction

4

Improvement (small)

19

Sheridan

4

Improvement (large)

23

Central Iowa

4

Improvement (small)

23

Fargo

4

Improvement (small)

23

Minneapolis

4

No change

23

Omaha

4

No change

23

Sioux Falls

4

No change

1

Bedford

5

No change

1

Connecticut

5

Improvement (small)

1

Northampton

5

Improvement (large)

1

Togus

5

Improvement (large)

2

Bath

5

Improvement (small)

4

Butler

5

Decline in performance

4

Coatesville

5

No change

4

Erie

5

Improvement (small)

4

Lebanon

5

Improvement (small)

6

Asheville

5

Improvement (large)

6

Salem

5

Improvement (small)

10

Cincinnati

5

Improvement (small)

10

Cleveland

5

Improvement (small)

10

Saginaw

5

Improvement (large)

12

Iron Mountain

5

Improvement (small)

12

Madison

5

Improvement (small)

23

Hot Springs

5

Improvement (large)

23

St Cloud

5

Improvement (small)

 

 
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of FRA.